CDC Warning: The Eye Drop Danger Lurking in Your Medicine Cabinet

By American Society for MicrobiologyMay 15, 2023

In February 2023, the CDC warned against using EzriCare eye drops due to links with drug-resistant bacterial infections causing vision loss and even death. An interdisciplinary group of researchers and physicians in Cleveland, Ohio, have now published a case study from November 2022, detailing a 72-year-old female patient's corneal ulcer caused by the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The patient's contaminated eye drops were identified as the source of the infection, which was treated with strong antibiotics. Since the CDC's warning, infectious cases involving P. aeruginosa have been identified as far back as spring 2022. Despite the product's removal from stores, it may still pose a risk to those who have it in their medicine cabinets.

The CDC warned against using EzriCare eye drops after they were linked to drug-resistant bacterial infections, vision loss, and death. Researchers have now detailed a case of a corneal ulcer caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa, which was traced back to contaminated eye drops. Although the product has been removed from stores, it may still pose a risk.

In February 2023, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warned people against using EzriCare eye drops because bottles of the product had been linked to drug-resistant bacterial infections causing vision loss and even death. But tainted bottles had been causing problems long before then.

Last week in the journal Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, an interdisciplinary group of researchers and physicians in Cleveland, Ohio, describe a case from November 2022. The patient, a 72-year-old female, was diagnosed with a corneal ulcer, caused by infection by the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Eventually, infectious disease physicians and microbiologists identified her contaminated eye drops as the source of the infection.

P. aeruginosa is a pathogenic, gram-negative bacterium that's resistant to treatment with most antibiotics. It can cause swimmer's ear — a painful infection of the outer ear canal — and more serious conditions, especially in people with compromised immune systems. But the case in Cleveland was unusual, said Morgan Morelli, M.D., the study's first author and an infectious disease fellow at the hospital.

"I’ve never recovered it from an eye," she said. Because P. aeruginosa isn't usually found in eye infections, she said, finding the right diagnosis was a challenge. "It required a lot of thinking and digging to figure out what was going on," she said. "And we never thought it was related to a global manufacturing issue."

The patient initially reported to an outpatient eye clinic with blurry vision. From there, she was sent to the emergency department at the hospital, where she was evaluated by ophthalmologists. They cultured the infection, prescribed a combination of strong antibiotic eye drops, and sent her home. But the next day, the eye was worse—and she visited a cornea specialist.

The patient had noticed a yellow discharge on her pillow, and she hadn't been swimming. "We wondered if she’d accidentally touched something, or there was some freak accident," to explain the infection, Morelli said.

At that point, Morelli said, her case was referred to microbiologists and infectious disease experts at the hospital. Infectious disease specialist Scott Fulton, M.D., asked the patient's husband to bring in her eye drops for testing. A sample from the patient was sent to the lab of Robert Bonomo, M.D., an expert in gram-negative, drug-resistant bacteria at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine.

Then, Morelli said, the pieces came together. Dr. Bonomo's lab identified a P. aeruginosa isolate that matched genetic material found in the EzriCare artificial tear eye drops she’d been using. Then researchers connected the eye infection—and the ulcer it had caused—to the contaminated drops.

Treatment was tricky, Morelli said. The isolate was resistant to any antibiotics that could be administered by way of the patient's eye. She was treated instead by a strong antibiotic, cefiderocol, that has some activity against gram-negative bacterium, as well as two other topical antibiotics. The injury to her eye improved, Morelli said, but it's unclear whether the patient will ever regain total vision.

Since issuing the warning in February, the CDC has identified infectious cases due to P. aeruginosa as early as spring 2022. "I think it took a while for this to be put together, in terms of what all these patients had in common," said Morelli. Although the contaminated product has been pulled from stores and can no longer be purchased, it may still pose a risk.

People may still have it on their medicine cabinet shelves, Morelli said. She also hopes that the ophthalmologists and optometrists who may be the first physicians to see future patients with this infection will know what to look for. "We don't always get this detailed of a history or ask someone to bring in over-the-counter medicine they’re using," she said. "We really wanted to raise awareness."

Reference: "Investigating and Treating a Corneal Ulcer Due to Extensively Drug-Resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa" by Morgan K. Morelli, Amy Kloosterboer, Scott A. Fulton, Jennifer Furin, Nicholas Newman, Ahmed F. Omar, Laura J. Rojas, Steven H. Marshall, Mohamad Yasmin and Robert A. Bonomo, 11 May 2023, Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy.DOI: 10.1128/aac.00277-23